Started with a larger sharpie. Should I keep going?
a buttsharpie classic
A perfect fit
Taste the Rainbow
Wife is back, 3 magnums + 6 regular
These guys just wouldn’t stay in!
It took more training than I'd like to admit but I've [f]inally fit 12 in me!
Great pencil case for your markers
[self] butt sharpies: back to school edition
Think I'll (f)it in here?
[Self] buttsharpie for my birthday
First time posting, won't be the last.
Not the best picture, but I was dared to see how many I could (f)it
The Poor College Girl Masturbation Starter Pack
She got 6 on her first go. We could have done more but they're so slippery.
First time trying this. 15 Sharpies!!!
Not the only thing that’s been up my booty... (f)irst [self] post
9 and it felt fine. New PR for this 32 [F]. God bless America.
2 to start
up it goes
Wife wanted to try again, got 18 this time
(self) First attempt – I’ll be sure to fit more next time ;)
Great couples activity. First time ever, looking to beat the record soon. 5/7 perfect score.
[F]irst post here. Only 2 so far :)
Once we found about this sub, my g[f] was adamant that we contribute.
I shattered my recored with 9 sharpies! (F)
Would love to see someone go for 10 of these!
Wi(f)e wanted to try the magnum sharpies, next time she says she wants to see how many regular sharpies will fit with these
I was trying to be productive, then my new “King Size” Sharpie came in the mail. Played with my ass instead. No regrets.
I could only find one which is boring but the angle looks great!
Found this one a while back
[s] Up to 17 for Sir
In her final appearance I present a new record, 23 sharpies!
I definitely liked the feel of the double penetration. However, the Sharpie Magnum did not slide in easy
[self] First Attempt and first post. I think I'm going to love it here
My new personal best- 11! :) [f]
Five for my first time.
[Self] First time for everything? And loved it.
Heard my NS[F]W work post belonged here
8 on the first try!
First Challenge - My friend told me 14 was the record and 15 seemed stupidly easy
10 on the first try
New record of [f]our from work today;)
Blonde Taking a Few Sharpies
A butt load
I asked my girlfriend if I could fill her ass, she said yes.. 7 is a great start!
sharpied for the first time [self]
[self] 14 sharpies. Working up to getting my fist in my asshole.
Bored at work so I played a little bit [f]
Sara Rose masturbating with a sharpie in her butt and a bullet in her pussy