[self] 14 sharpies. Working up to getting my fist in my asshole.
sharpied for the first time [self]
first time, go big or go home right? [self]
I asked my girlfriend if I could fill her ass, she said yes.. 7 is a great start!
A butt load
Blonde Taking a Few Sharpies
8 on the first try!
Goal was 6. We fit 10. I love her initiative. More to come!
Up to 11! Bite marks extra credit?
In her final appearance I present a new record, 23 sharpies!
[s] Up to 17 for Sir
I was trying to be productive, then my new “King Size” Sharpie came in the mail. Played with my ass instead. No regrets.
Would love to see someone go for 10 of these!
I definitely liked the feel of the double penetration. However, the Sharpie Magnum did not slide in easy
up it goes
Great couples activity. First time ever, looking to beat the record soon. 5/7 perfect score.
Think I'll (f)it in here?
Wife is back, 3 magnums + 6 regular
Taste the Rainbow
Started with a larger sharpie. Should I keep going?
[S] 16 sharpies - The sharpies and fisting are a task for Sir
[self] Three for me! :)
Lana
[F] I was told to put this here. I only got 1 with a bit of struggle!
Just found this from another sub.
Butt Sharpies, inspired by butt Sharpies
[f]irst time!! Hope to go for more!
12 for Sir
Here's 11! More to come!
First post! We’ll have to buy more sharpies for next time
I stretched my ass with 13. For "Sir" :)
Lucky number 3
Motivated for 5 ;)
Just (2) to start...Hope to get a (f)ew more in the future. [Self]
She's new at butt Sharpies but giving it her best
[hers]
[self] [F]irst try, got 8! (repost with rule compliance)
Mylene the champion with 22 (album)
My first one!
[F]irst time here, celebrating my cake day ;)
I'm new to this sharpie thing, how did I do?
My submissive would like to present you with her gift to the ButtSharpie community. Enjoy!
[Self] buttsharpie for my birthday
Did my [f]irst buttsharpie for Daddy. Tonight I'm going to try 2!
a buttsharpie classic
Buttsharpies Verification (F)
[Self] buttsharpie for my birthday
a buttsharpie classic
That's a big sharpie [x-post from /r/buttsharpies]